How to analyze YouTube comments for customer research: 7 steps and 283 coded comments
A step-by-step method for turning YouTube comments into customer research, tested on 283 real comments from three software videos, with the counts, the quotes and the limits.
How to analyze YouTube comments for customer research
Quick answer: to analyze YouTube comments for customer research, pick videos where buyers compare or learn a product, export 100+ comments, drop creator and promo comments, code each comment as a pick request, how-to question, complaint or praise, count the codes, and quote the best lines. BigIdeasDB Desktop’s YouTube Lab collects and counts them on your own computer.
What our data adds: in 283 comments coded by hand from three accounting-software videos (YouTube Data API, November 2026), 63.6% carried a buyer signal and only 26.1% were plain praise.
YouTube comment analysis for customer research means reading what viewers write under videos about a product or problem, sorting each comment into a type, and counting the types. It is not creator analytics. You are not asking how your own video did. You are asking what buyers want, doubt and complain about. BigIdeasDB Desktop is a local-first research app for Mac and Windows that collects evidence from Reddit, Google Trends, YouTube and more on your own computer and uses your own AI agent for analysis. Read the Desktop overview for the full list.
The searches for this topic are mostly served by tools that score comment mood for creators. Nothing on the first page of Google (US, November 17, 2026) shows a buyer-research method with counted examples, so this page runs one end to end. For finding the videos first, read how to find outlier videos on YouTube. For the wider method, see voice of customer research and customer review analysis.
“Out of 100 comments, I’d say about 80 are things like “Great video!”, “Thanks for the content” or “First!”. The remaining 20% often contain really valuable insights.”via r/NewTubers, how to analyze YouTube comments
The 7 steps to analyze YouTube comments, in order
| Step | What you do | The rule | The number |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Pick videos where your buyers talk | Rank by comments, not views | 1.9M views, 6 comments on one invoicing video |
| 2 | Export the comments | 100+ top-level comments per video | 283 pulled from 3 videos in minutes |
| 3 | Clean the pile | Drop creator, promo, duplicates | 4 promo comments and 1 duplicate in 283 |
| 4 | Code every comment | One code each, 8 to 10 codes | 10 codes covered all 283 |
| 5 | Count the codes | Shares per code and per video | 63.6% buyer signal, 26.1% praise |
| 6 | Quote the best lines | 3 to 5 verbatim lines per code | 13 price comments, the top one with 20 likes |
| 7 | Turn counts into a decision | One sentence per finding | 6 of 85 asked for a landlord version |
Step 1: pick videos where your buyers talk
Choose videos where buyers compare, review or learn a product, and rank them by comment count, not views. A search for best invoicing software for small business contractors returned about 365,000 results on YouTube, and the most viewed medium-length result had 1,900,000+ views and 6 comments (YouTube Data API, November 17, 2026).
Views tell you reach. Comments tell you who is willing to type. Look for three video types: comparisons (software A vs software B), tutorials for new users, and review or alternative videos. Skip pure ads and general explainers, where viewers are learners, not buyers.
| Video | Views | Comments | Our call |
|---|---|---|---|
| Phone invoicing app demo | 1,900,000+ | 6 | Skip: an ad, almost no comments |
| Invoice basics explainer | 880,000+ | 812 | Skip for buyer research: learners, not buyers |
| Software tutorial A | 350,000+ | 199 | Use: setup questions from new users |
| Free software tutorial B | 170,000+ | 250 | Use: switching and cost doubts |
| Top 5 CRM tools | 130,000+ | 197 | Possible: a different job |
| Payroll services review | 110,000+ | 194 | Possible: a different job |
| Software A vs software B | 80,000+ | 255 | Use: viewers say which they would pick |
We used the comparison and the two tutorials. The Desktop YouTube Lab does this selection for you: you type a phrase such as best ___, ___ alternative, ___ review or ___ vs, press Check now, and it opens the most viewed videos for that search. By default it opens the 12 most viewed, and at most 25 (YouTube Lab guide). Its outlier chart shows videos that beat their channel size, which is the other way to find where buyers gather.
Step 2: how to export YouTube comments
You can export YouTube comments with the free YouTube Data API, a copy-and-paste export, or the BigIdeasDB Desktop YouTube Lab. The API returns up to 100 top-level threads per request, and we pulled 100 threads from each of three videos in one call each (YouTube Data API, November 2026).
Ranked by fit for customer research, here are the five ways to collect comments.
| Rank | Method | What it gives | Best for | Limit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | BigIdeasDB Desktop YouTube Lab | Saved searches, top comments of the most viewed videos, theme counts with word-for-word quotes, runs on your own computer | Best for repeat checks on a niche | Comments are what the check fetched, not all of them; themes are phrase counts |
| 2 | YouTube Data API with an AI agent | Any video, up to 100 threads per page, structured fields | Best for a one-off study like the one on this page | Needs a free API key and a script or agent |
| 3 | Copy and paste into ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini | Zero setup, good for 50 to 200 comments | Best for a quick first read | Manual copying, context limits, no counts you can trust without checking |
| 4 | Spreadsheet by hand | Full control of the codebook | Best for under 100 comments | Slow; coding drifts after the first 50 |
| 5 | YouTube Studio comment filters | Free, built in | Best for your own channel | Your own videos only; no export of competitors |
The Desktop YouTube Lab ranks first because it is the only option here built for the job. It reads top comments, channel size and upload day for the videos it opens, requests go out one every 1.5 seconds from your computer, and a check takes a couple of minutes while you keep working. It needs no account, and a YouTube key is optional: a free key you add yourself sizes every channel. Comment counts are what the check fetched, not every comment on the video. Details are in the YouTube Lab guide and the research sources guide.
We did not use the Lab for the worked example below. We pulled the comments with the YouTube Data API through an AI agent and coded them by hand, so every number on this page can be checked against the method, not against a screenshot.
Step 3: clean the pile before you count
Remove the creator’s own comments, promotions for other products and duplicates before you count anything. In our pull, the creator had left their own comments on each video (1, 1 and 15), 4 of the 283 remaining comments were promotions for another product, and one question was posted twice word for word.
Three more rules keep the counts honest. Drop usernames and channel IDs. Read top-level threads only and say so, because replies change the mix. And write down your sort order: we used relevance, which floats longer threads and liked comments up. Our praise share (26.1%) is lower than the 80% a creator on Reddit reported for their own channel, and the sort order is one reason.
Two quick filters help when the pile is large. Neither is safe alone, as the table shows.
| Filter | Comments kept | Signal comments kept | What you lose |
|---|---|---|---|
| Keep only comments with a question mark | 105 | 98 of 180 signal comments | 82 of 180 (45.6%) missed |
| Keep only comments of 12+ words | 171 | 142 of 180 signal comments | 38 of 180 (21.1%) missed, 13 of 74 praise kept |
| Read everything | 283 | 180 of 180 | 0 missed, 100% of the effort |
A question-mark filter, the usual tip, misses 45.6% of the signal, because complaints and price remarks rarely ask anything. A length filter works better: praise has a median of 5 words and buyer-signal comments a median of 19 to 20. Use 12+ words to triage, then read what you dropped for a minute.
Step 4: YouTube comment analysis, one code per comment
YouTube comment analysis for customer research is coding: give every comment exactly one code from a short codebook, so counts add up to 100%. Our codebook has 9 rows and covered all 283 comments, with the rules written down before coding started.
| Code | Typical comment | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Pick request | Which should I pick for my business? | Asks a recommendation for a named business type |
| How-to question | How do I set this up or do that task? | Setup, import, reporting questions |
| Product complaint or unmet need | It is complicated, buggy, missing a feature | Names a failure or a gap |
| Price complaint or cost doubt | Renewal went up, what is the catch? | Mentions cost, price or free |
| Switching or import | How do I move my data from the old tool? | Names the tool being left |
| Integration question | Does it connect to my store or bank? | Names another tool or channel |
| Video or use-case request | Can you do one for landlords? | Asks for content for a segment |
| Praise | Thanks, great video | No question, no complaint, no detail |
| Other or promo | Jokes, spam, a plug for another product | Carries no buyer signal |
Buyer research uses the four classic groups: pains (complaints and unmet needs), wants (requests and pick questions), objections (price and cost doubts) and language (the exact words). Add a segment tag when the viewer names a trade, because the segment is often the finding. The Desktop Lab automates one slice of this: its Voices view counts pain phrases such as too expensive or I wish there was and marks the matched phrase inside each word-for-word quote. It uses no hosted AI and gives no sentiment score, and a phrase match is a sign, not proof (Honest limits). You can also ask your own AI agent to refine the themes through the Desktop tools.
Step 5: count the codes and compare videos
Count comments per code overall and per video, then compare. Across the three videos, 180 of 283 comments (63.6%) carried a buyer signal: a pick request, how-to question, complaint, price remark, switching question, integration question or use-case request.
| Code | Comments | Share of 283 | Median words |
|---|---|---|---|
| Praise or thanks | 74 | 26.1% | 5 |
| How-to question (setup, tasks) | 63 | 22.3% | 19 |
| Pick request for a named business | 54 | 19.1% | 19 |
| Product complaint or unmet need | 26 | 9.2% | 20 |
| Other (jokes, one-liners, off topic) | 25 | 8.8% | n/a |
| Price complaint or cost doubt | 13 | 4.6% | n/a |
| Switching or data import | 10 | 3.5% | n/a |
| Integration question | 8 | 2.8% | n/a |
| Video or use-case request | 6 | 2.1% | n/a |
| Promo for another product | 4 | 1.4% | n/a |
| Video | Comments | Top code | Second code | Next |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Software A vs software B (comparison) | 99 | Pick request 53 (53.5%) | Praise 14 (14.1%) | Price 8, product 6 |
| Free software B tutorial | 99 | How-to 41 (41.4%) | Praise 25 (25.3%) | Product 12, switching 8 |
| Software A tutorial | 85 | Praise 35 (41.2%) | How-to 18 (21.2%) | Product 8, integration 5 |
The mix depends on the video. The comparison video drew 53 pick requests out of 99 comments (53.5%), people naming their business and asking which to buy. The free-software tutorial drew 41 how-to questions (41.4%), the sound of new users stuck on setup. The first is a demand signal for buyers. The second is a support gap you could sell into.
Do not count likes as votes. One joke comment held 145 of the 338 likes in the whole sample (42.9%), while the price complaints carried 26. Count comments, then read likes only inside a code.
What did 283 YouTube comments say?
Viewers listed the exact customer segments, price complaints and unmet needs that a software builder would want. Of 54 pick requests, the viewers named a barber and stylist, food trucks, a pool cleaner, a landscaper, an electrician, a three-person auto repair shop, a small nonprofit and a dance school (YouTube Data API comments, November 2026).
Three findings stand out. First, segment demand: on the tutorial for one accounting package, 6 of 85 viewers (7.1%) asked for a version for landlords or rental property management, and the asks were specific.
“I have a real estate company I want to know how to best show a record of each property I manage totalling each category ie rent received payments but tenants and expenses paid by owners”YouTube comment on an accounting software tutorial
Second, price anger is real but small: 13 of 283 comments (4.6%) were price complaints or cost doubts, and the sharpest was the most liked complaint at 20 likes.
“Quickbooks just raised renewal cost nearly 50%. Quickbooks can shove it”YouTube comment on an accounting software comparison, 20 likes
Third, the unmet need is simplicity. Product complaints (26 comments, 9.2%) cluster on complexity and missing basics, and two viewers, unprompted, asked for the smaller product.
“Why can’t I just find a simple app to track money in and money out. Nothing more.”YouTube comment on an accounting software comparison
None of this proves a market. It tells you where to look next: a landlord version, a simpler product, a setup service. One more commenter wrote “I WOULD PAY SOMEONE TO SET THIS UP FOR ME,” which is the cleanest willingness-to-pay line in the sample, from a single person.
Step 6: quote the best lines, word for word
Keep three to five verbatim lines per code and attribute them to the platform only. The viewer’s exact words are the research output: they become your headline, your landing page copy and the questions you ask in interviews. In our sample the most useful line was a feature ask with 9 likes.
“Can you set rules to categorize automatically income/expenses transactions?”YouTube comment on a free accounting software tutorial, 9 likes
Rules for quotes: never edit the words, strip names and channel IDs, pick lines that carry a number, a trade or a decision, and keep the code next to the quote so you can recount later. The Desktop Lab keeps this structure for you: it marks the matched phrase in each quote, and you can pin a theme with its quotes, or a single comment, to the evidence board.
Step 7: turn the counts into a decision
Write one sentence per finding in the form code, count, action, and test the top finding in a second source before you act. A good finding from this study reads: 6 of 85 tutorial viewers asked for a landlord version, so check Reddit landlord threads and review sites for the same ask.
Pair comments with sources that behave differently. Reddit threads show buyers describing the whole problem, reviews show what paying users regret, and comments show what people ask at the moment they choose. Read customer pain point analysis for the pain side and market gap analysis to see whether the gap is open. To find where else your buyers gather, see how to find online communities for your niche, and to run the Desktop workflow through an AI agent see Claude Code market research. Before you build, run how to validate a startup idea.
YouTube comments sentiment analysis: do you need it?
For customer research, sentiment analysis adds little: it labels the mood but not the job, and 63.6% of our comments carried a signal that a positive or negative label blurs together. A complaint about price and a question about setup can both read as mildly negative.
Code by type first. If you still want a mood number, add one column (positive, neutral, negative) to the same sheet and compare it by code. Tools that score sentiment for creators also admit their limits: the free analyzer at the top of Google says AI can misread sarcasm, jokes and missing context. Our sample had jokes in it, including the 145-like one, which a mood score would count as positive.
Can ChatGPT analyse a YouTube video?
ChatGPT can analyze text you give it, such as exported comments or a pasted transcript, and returns summaries and theme lists fast. We did not test whether it can fetch a video link on its own, so check what your plan supports (Google People Also Ask, US, November 17, 2026).
A safe workflow: paste 100 to 200 comments, paste your codebook, ask for one code per comment as a table, then check 20 labels by hand. Be careful with transcripts: YouTube is not giving captions to apps right now, so BigIdeasDB Desktop reports a transcript as unavailable (research sources guide). Comments and descriptions are the dependable text.
What this cannot tell you
- Comments skew to engaged viewers. Most viewers never comment, and the ones who do are in a buying or learning moment. As one r/SaaS reply put it, people do not go around YouTube commenting that they have no idea what to build.
- One topic, three videos. The percentages describe accounting-software comments, not YouTube in general. A different niche will have a different mix.
- Top-level comments, relevance order. Replies were not read, and relevance order floats longer and liked threads, which lowers the praise share.
- Single coder. The coding was done once by one reviewer with a written codebook. Borderline comments (for example, a pick request that also complains about price) took the first rule that matched.
- Comments are not demand. A request from 6 viewers is a lead to test, not market size. Confirm in reviews, Reddit or interviews.
- Likes are noisy. One joke held 42.9% of all likes in the sample.
- The Desktop Lab counts phrases, not meaning. Channel size is known only for videos it opens unless you add your own key, and upload dates are approximate.
Methodology and data sources
Population. Top-level comments, up to 100 per video in relevance order, from three accounting-software videos found through a YouTube Data API search on November 17, 2026: a comparison (80,000+ views, 255 comments listed), a free-software tutorial (170,000+ views, 250 listed) and a paid-software tutorial (350,000+ views, 199 listed). The creator’s own comments were removed, leaving 99, 99 and 85. Each of the 283 comments got one code from the codebook above. Percentages divide by 283.
| Source | What it gives | Size | Limitation |
|---|---|---|---|
| YouTube Data API: search and comments | Views, comment counts, top-level comments with likes | 10 search results, 283 comments | One niche, relevance order, replies not read, hand-coded by one reviewer |
| Google SERP and People Also Ask | The questions searchers ask and what ranks | US, November 17, 2026 | Ranking snapshot; no search volumes |
| Reddit threads (r/NewTubers, r/SaaS) | Creator and builder voice on comment analysis | 2 threads | Anecdote; the 80% praise claim is one poster’s own channel |
| BigIdeasDB Desktop docs | What the YouTube Lab collects, counts and cannot do | Product documentation | Describes the Lab, not our worked example |
For the research source list, see the Desktop research sources guide. For the evidence board, see the evidence board guide. If your reading is mostly Reddit, Reddit market research covers that side.
Find what buyers in your niche say next
Comments tell you what buyers ask in the moment. Scan your niche in BigIdeasDB to see 1M+ documented complaints, what the competition lacks and where the gap is open, then collect YouTube evidence on your own computer with BigIdeasDB Desktop. Get 20% off Pro Lifetime with code SAVE20.
Scan your niche free →Try a scan on invoicing software, landlord software or food truck.
Frequently asked questions
How can I analyze YouTube comments?
Pick videos where your buyers compare or learn a product, export at least 100 top-level comments per video, drop creator and promo comments, give each comment one code such as pick request, how-to question, complaint or praise, then count the codes and quote the best lines. In our sample of 283 comments, 63.6% carried a buyer signal.
How do I export YouTube comments?
Use the free YouTube Data API, which returns up to 100 top-level threads per request, or copy comments by hand for small jobs. BigIdeasDB Desktop's YouTube Lab collects the top comments of the most viewed videos for a search on your own computer, by default from 12 videos and at most 25. Always drop the creator's own comments before counting.
What is the best tool for analyzing YouTube comments for customer research?
BigIdeasDB Desktop is the best tool for it, because its YouTube Lab searches a phrase such as best ___ or ___ alternative, reads the top comments of the most viewed videos and counts complaint themes with word-for-word quotes. It runs on your own Mac or Windows computer with no account. You can pin any theme to the evidence board.
What's the best way to get customer language from YouTube?
BigIdeasDB's Desktop YouTube Lab is the best way to start, because it returns the matched phrase inside each word-for-word comment, ranked by theme, so you copy the buyer's words instead of paraphrasing them. Then confirm the top theme in a second source, such as Reddit threads or reviews, before you build or buy anything around it.
Can ChatGPT analyse a YouTube video?
ChatGPT can analyze text you give it, such as exported comments or a transcript pasted into the chat. We did not test whether it can fetch a video link by itself, so check your plan. Paste 100 to 200 comments with your codebook and ask for counts, then spot-check 20 of its labels by hand, because summaries can miss sarcasm.
How many YouTube comments do I need to analyze?
Aim for at least 100 top-level comments per video and 200 or more across two or three videos, so one loud thread cannot decide the result. Our study used 283 comments from 3 videos. A single comment can dominate on likes: one joke held 145 of the 338 likes in our sample, so count comments, not likes.
Is YouTube comments sentiment analysis useful for customer research?
Only a little. A positive or negative score tells you the mood, not the job. In our sample 26.1% of comments were plain praise, and the useful 63.6% were questions, complaints and price remarks that a mood score blurs together. Code by type first (pick request, how-to, complaint), then add sentiment only if you need it.
Are YouTube comments good for customer research?
Yes for a first read of what buyers ask, compare and complain about, with limits. Commenters skew to engaged viewers, and one Reddit user warned that people do not go around YouTube saying they have no idea what to build. Treat comments as leads to confirm in reviews, Reddit or interviews, not as proof of demand.
How do I analyze YouTube comments for free?
Use the free YouTube Data API or copy comments by hand, put them in a sheet, and give each comment one code such as pick request, how-to question, complaint or praise. Count the codes and quote the best lines. It is free but slow, so aim for 100 to 200 top-level comments per video and drop the creator's own replies first.
Is there an AI that can analyze YouTube comments?
Yes. An AI assistant can code and count comments you paste in. Give it your codebook, ask for counts per code with one quote each, then spot-check 20 labels by hand, because summaries can miss sarcasm. BigIdeasDB Desktop's YouTube Lab collects the comments first, so the AI works from a saved, sourced dataset.
How do I find what viewers are asking in YouTube comments?
Collect top-level comments from the most viewed videos for a buyer phrase such as best ___ or ___ alternative, then code each comment as a question, a complaint, a pick request or praise. Filter to questions and sort by how often the same one repeats. In our sample of 283 comments, 63.6% carried a buyer signal.
What is a YouTube comment analyzer?
A YouTube comment analyzer is a tool or process that collects a video's comments and sorts them into themes, questions and sentiment. Many stop at a mood score. For customer research, code by type first (pick request, how-to, complaint) so you can see what buyers ask for, then keep the exact wording as quotes.
What is the best way to find buyer complaints in YouTube comments?
BigIdeasDB Desktop is the best way, because its YouTube Lab searches a phrase, reads the top comments of the most viewed videos and groups them into complaint themes with word-for-word quotes. It runs on your Mac or Windows computer, and you can pin any theme to the evidence board. Confirm the top theme in Reddit threads or reviews.
How do I analyze the comments on a competitor's YouTube video?
Pick two or three videos where buyers compare or review the product, export at least 100 top-level comments from each, and drop the creator's and any promo comments. Code each comment, count the codes, and quote the best lines. Count comments, not likes, because one joke can hold a large share of the likes.
BigIdeasDB Research. (2026). How to analyze YouTube comments for customer research: 7 steps and 283 coded comments. BigIdeasDB. Retrieved from https://bigideasdb.com/how-to-analyze-youtube-comments